That how I train my dog to be good and get love when she good and not love when she bad. I hope your are happeir with your dog

He was always naughty we rolled up paper into a smack stick when he played up it was a tap on the nose and chained to the leash for an hour with no treat or loving but when he listened we told him good boy and gave lots of love and cuddles after a couple of weeks of this constant treatment he soon realized kisses and cuddles was better then being chained to the fence he is now 1yr old and is a gem every now and then of course just like a child he will test us and back to the chain and lonely fence he goes.

you give him a teart right why noy try give him love and is he a type where beg for food when you have dinnier put him in to your room or some place he will know beg not good. and when he just be naughty tell him off and put in a room. and don,t give him love into a half hour:) i hope this help